AMC 10 · 2005 · #4

Grade 8 arithmetic
function-evaluationexponentsperfect-squares identify-subproblemsformula-substitution ↑ Prerequisites: exponentsfunction-evaluation
📏 Short solution 💡 2 insights
Problem
A new operation is defined by a ◆ b = √(a² + b²) for real numbers a and b. Using this rule, find the value of (5 ◆ 12) ◆ ((-12) ◆ (-5)).

Pick an answer.

(A)
0
(B)
$\frac{17}{2}$
(C)
13
(D)
$13\sqrt{2}$
(E)
26

AMC 10 2005 problem © Mathematical Association of America (MAA AMC). Reproduced for educational use.

How to solve
Strategy Identify Subproblems

The expression nests one diamond inside another, so Tool #7 (Identify Subproblems) is the natural fit: compute each inner diamond first, then feed the two results into the outer diamond. Tool #3 (Eliminate Possibilities) catches the built-in traps — reading ◆ as plain addition gives 13+13=26 (choice E), and forgetting the final square root of the sum leaves a bare 13 (choice C), so knowing the real rule steers past both.

1STEP 1

Apply the rule to 5 ♦ 12

Plug a=5, b=12 into √(a²+b²): 25+144 = 169, so 5 ◆ 12 = 13.

5 ◆ 12 = √(5²+12²) = √(25+144) = √(169) = 13
2STEP 2

Apply the rule to (-12) ♦ (-5)

Same rule with a=-12, b=-5: squaring erases the signs, so 144+25 = 169 and (-12) ◆ (-5) = 13 again.

(-12) ◆ (-5) = √((-12)²+(-5)²) = √(144+25) = √(169) = 13
3STEP 3

Feed both results into the outer diamond

Both inner values are 13, so the outer one is 13 ◆ 13 = √(169+169) = √(338).

13 ◆ 13 = √(13²+13²) = √(169+169) = √(338)
4STEP 4

Simplify the square root

Since 338 = 169·2 and 169 = 13² is a perfect square, √(338) = 13√(2) — choice (D).

√(338) = √(169 · 2) = √(169) √(2) = 13√(2) → (D)
Answer
13√(2)
Each inner diamond is the classic 5-12-13 right-triangle relationship, so both collapse to 13 — a clean whole number, a good sign the setup is right. The outer diamond then combines two equal 13s, and 13√(2) ≈ 13(1.414) ≈ 18.4 sits sensibly between 13 and 26: bigger than either input's raw value but smaller than their plain sum. Choices 0 and 17/2 are far too small, and 26 would require ◆ to be addition, which it is not.
💡Key takeaway

Work a nested custom operation from the inside out, and remember squaring wipes out minus signs — so the negatives here changed nothing.

  • Apply the rule to 5 ♦ 12
  • Apply the rule to (-12) ♦ (-5)
  • Feed both results into the outer diamond
  • Simplify the square root