AMC 10 · 2015 · #20

Grade 6 geometry-2d
area-rectanglesperimeterprime-numbers simons-favorite-factoring-trick ↑ Prerequisites: area-rectanglesperimeter
📏 Medium solution 💡 3 insights
Problem
A rectangle has whole-number side lengths. Its area is A and its perimeter is P. Of the five listed numbers, find the one that can never equal the sum A+P.

Pick an answer.

(A)
100
(B)
102
(C)
104
(D)
106
(E)
108

AMC 10 2015 problem © Mathematical Association of America (MAA AMC). Reproduced for educational use.

How to solve
Strategy Introduce a Variable

Tool #4 (Introduce a Variable) names the two sides a and b so that A+P becomes a single expression ab+2a+2b. The key move is a factoring trick: adding 4 turns that messy sum into the clean product (a+2)(b+2), so the whole problem reduces to a question about factor pairs. Tool #3 (Eliminate Possibilities) then fits perfectly because there are only five answer choices — a finite set — and we can test each one to see whether it survives. Tool #13 (Convert to Algebra) is the bridge that rewrites the geometry words 'area' and 'perimeter' into symbols we can manipulate.

1STEP 1

Name the sides, write A+P

Naming the sides a and b turns area and perimeter into one algebraic expression for A+P.

A+P = ab + 2a + 2b
2STEP 2

Add 4 and factor

Add 4 to complete the sum into the product (a+2)(b+2), so A+P equals that product minus 4.

A+P = (a+2)(b+2) - 4
3STEP 3

Turn it into a factor-pair test

Testing each choice shows 100, 104, 106, and 108 all split into two factors of N+4 that are at least 3.

(a+2)(b+2)=N+4, a+2 ≥ 3, b+2 ≥ 3
4STEP 4

The one that fails

106=2×53 leaves no factor pair both at least 3, so no rectangle gives A+P=102.

106 = 2× 53, 53 prime → no factor pair both ≥ 3 → (B)
Answer
102
The four passing choices each came with an explicit rectangle, so they are genuinely possible — for example sides 8 and 9 give A=72, P=34, A+P=106, matching choice (D). The failing choice 102 has N+4=106=2×53, whose only factor pairs are 1×106 and 2×53; both leave a factor below 3, meaning a side of 0 or less, which is impossible. The pattern is clean: a choice fails exactly when N+4 is twice a prime, and 106 is the only such value among 104,106,108,110,112.
💡Key takeaway

Area plus perimeter is (a+2)(b+2)-4, so a number is reachable only if adding 4 gives two factors both at least 3.

  • Name the sides, write A+P
  • Add 4 and factor
  • Turn it into a factor-pair test
  • The one that fails