AMC 10 · 2012 · #20

Grade 9 geometry-2d
area-trapezoidcoordinate-geometrypythagorean-theorempolygon-inequality systematic-enumerationconvert-to-algebracasework ↑ Prerequisites: area-trapezoidpythagorean-theorem
📏 Long solution 💡 4 insights
Problem
Four given lengths must be arranged into a trapezoid in every workable way. Combine the resulting areas as asked.

Pick an answer.

(A)
57
(B)
59
(C)
61
(D)
63
(E)
65
How to solve
Strategy Make a Systematic List

The phrase "all the possible areas" makes this a completeness problem, so tool #2 (Make a Systematic List) is the backbone: the list must contain every trapezoid and no duplicates. Two things have to be nailed down before any area is computed. First, how many cases there really are — naively 4!=24 orderings, but tool #2 plus a mirror-symmetry observation collapses this to the C(4, 2)=6 choices of which pair is parallel. Second, and this is where the problem is actually decided, a test for when a chosen arrangement exists at all. Tools #4 (Introduce a Variable) and #13 (Convert to Algebra) set up coordinates and solve for the height, and tool #9 (Solve an Easier Related Problem) converts "does this trapezoid exist?" into the far easier "do these three lengths form a triangle?" — as an if-and-only-if, so it both rules cases out and certifies the survivors. Tool #3 (Eliminate Possibilities) then screens the six candidates by arithmetic alone, tool #7 (Identify Subproblems) computes the three heights and areas, and tool #15 (Organize Information in More Ways) matches the total to the prescribed r₁√(n₁)+r₂√(n₂)+r₃ shape and checks that the match is forced, so the requested sum is well defined.

1STEP 1

Only the parallel pair matters

Only the parallel pair distinguishes the arrangements.

candidate parallel pairs: {3,5}, {3,7}, {3,11}, {5,7}, {5,11}, {7,11}
2STEP 2

Put the trapezoid on coordinates

Coordinates turn the shape into two unknowns.

d²=|DA|²=p²+h², b²=|CB|²=q²+h², p+q=c-a
3STEP 3

Solve for the offset and the height

Solving gives the offset and the height.

d²-b²=p²-q²=(p-q)t → p-q=(d²-b²)/t, p=(t²+d²-b²)/2t, h²=d²-p²
4STEP 4

Exists exactly when a triangle exists

Existence reduces to a triangle inequality.

h² > 0⇔ |p| < d⇔ (t-d)² < b² < (t+d)²⇔ |t-d| < b < t+d
5STEP 5

Screen the six candidates

Only three of the six arrangements survive.

{3,5}: & t=2, & legs 7,11: & 7+2=9 < 11 ✗ ; {3,7}: & t=4, & legs 5,11: & 5+4=9 < 11 ✗ ; {5,7}: & t=2, & legs 3,11: & 3+2=5 < 11 ✗ ; {3,11}: & t=8, & legs 5,7: & 5+7=12 > 8 ✓ ; {5,11}: & t=6, & legs 3,7: & 3+6=9 > 7 ✓ ; {7,11}: & t=4, & legs 3,5: & 3+4=7 > 5 ✓
6STEP 6

Compute the three areas

Each survivor gives a clean area.

{3,11}, d=5,b=7,t=8:& p=(64+25-49)/16=5/2, h=√(25-25/4)=5√3/2, S=(3+11)/2·5√3/2=35√3/2 ; {5,11}, d=3,b=7,t=6:& p=(36+9-49)/12=-1/3, h=√(9-1/9)=4√5/3, S=(5+11)/2·4√5/3=32√5/3 ; {7,11}, d=3,b=5,t=4:& p=(16+9-25)/8=0, h=3, S=(7+11)/2 · 3=27
7STEP 7

Match the form and take the floor

Matching the form and rounding down gives 63.

r₁+r₂+r₃+n₁+n₂=35/2+32/3+27+3+5=169/6+35=379/6=631/6, ⌊ 379/6⌋ = 63
Answer
63
Sanity-check each area against a crude bound. A trapezoid with parallel sides a,c and legs b,d has height at most min(b,d), so its area is at most (a+c)/2min(b,d): for {3,11} that ceiling is 7 · 5=35 and the area is 30.31; for {5,11} it is 8 · 3=24 and the area is 23.85; for {7,11} it is 9 · 3=27, met exactly because that leg is perpendicular — a good consistency signal, since p=0 predicted a right angle. Each case can also be checked by its legs: for {3,11}, p=5/2 and q=8-5/2=11/2 give √((5/2)²+75/4)=5 and √((11/2)²+75/4)=7, the correct legs. Finally the value 379/6=63.16 sits just above 63; the nearest choices 61 and 65 are far away, so no rounding slip can flip the letter, and (D) stands.
💡Key takeaway

Only the choice of which two sides are parallel matters, and such a trapezoid exists exactly when the two legs and the overhang c-a can form a triangle — three of the six choices pass, and their areas add to 35√3/2+32√5/3+27.

  • Only the parallel pair matters
  • Put the trapezoid on coordinates
  • Solve for the offset and the height
  • Exists exactly when a triangle exists
  • Screen the six candidates
  • Compute the three areas
  • Match the form and take the floor