AMC 10 · 2013 · #21

Grade 11 geometry-2dcounting
parabola-focus-directrixcoordinate-geometrycombinations-basicquadratic-equations convert-to-algebracomplementary-countingidentify-subproblems ↑ Prerequisites: parabola-focus-directrixcombinations-basic
📏 Long solution 💡 4 insights
Problem
Many curves share one focus and have directrices drawn from a small grid. Count the shared points.

Pick an answer.

(A)
720
(B)
760
(C)
810
(D)
840
(E)
870
How to solve
Strategy Convert to Algebra

Tool #13 (Convert to Algebra): write each parabola as one equation with the focus distance √(x²+y²) standing alone on the left. Then the shared focus becomes an algebraic gift — for two parabolas the left sides are identical, so subtracting the equations destroys the square root and leaves a straight line. Tool #4 (Introduce a Variable): compress each parabola into just two pieces of data, the focus-to-directrix distance p and a unit vector (u,v) giving the direction it opens; every claim below is a statement about those. Tool #15 (Organize in More Ways): the useful way to sort the 435 pairs is not by whether the directrices are parallel but by whether the two parabolas open in the same direction — a different, finer split. Tool #16 (Count the Complement): count the few pairs that miss each other, not the many that meet. Tool #7 (Subproblems): settle 'how many points per pair' completely first, then do the counting.

1STEP 1

Remove the absolute value

The sign lets the absolute value go.

ε = b/|b|, √(x²+y²) = (ε (ax - y + b))/(√(a²+1))
2STEP 2

A parabola is two numbers

Each curve is then just two numbers.

√(x²+y²) = p + ux + vy, p = |b|/(√(a²+1)) > 0, u² + v² = 1
3STEP 3

Subtract; the root cancels

Subtracting two kills the square root.

p₁ + u₁x + v₁y = √(x²+y²) = p₂ + u₂x + v₂y ⟹ (u₁-u₂)x + (v₁-v₂)y = p₂ - p₁
4STEP 4

Same direction means no meeting

Curves facing the same way never meet.

5 · ( C(3, 2) + C(3, 2) ) = 5 · 6 = 30 pairs with no common point
5STEP 5

Different directions: aim the line

Otherwise the line can be aimed conveniently.

y₀ = (p₂ - p₁)/2sinθ, p₁ + y₀sinθ = (p₁+p₂)/2 =: m, √(x² + y₀²) = m + xcosθ
6STEP 6

One quadratic, discriminant p₁p₂

One quadratic has a positive discriminant.

x²sin²θ - 2mxcosθ + (y₀² - m²) = 0, D/4 = m² - (y₀sinθ)² = ((p₁+p₂)/2)² - ((p₂-p₁)/2)² = p₁p₂
7STEP 7

Both roots are real points

Both roots are genuine points.

x = (mcosθ ± √(p₁p₂))/sin²θ, m + xcosθ = (m ± cosθ√(p₁p₂))/sin²θ > 0
8STEP 8

Count the pairs that fail

So 405 pairs meet twice each.

C(30, 2) - 30 = 435 - 30 = 405 pairs that each meet twice
9STEP 9

Multiply and finish

Doubling gives 810, choice (C).

2 · 405 = 810 → (C)
Answer
810
The ceiling is 2C(30, 2) = 870, choice (E) — what you get by assuming every pair meets twice — and 810 sits just under it, short by 60 = 2 · 30, a small and checkable deficit. Spot-check both cases by hand with a = 0. Directrix y = 1 gives y = (1-x²)/2 and directrix y = 2 gives y = 1 - x²/4; setting them equal gives x² = -2, no real point, matching the nested case. Directrix y = -1 gives y = (x²-1)/2, and (1-x²)/2 = (x²-1)/2 gives x = ± 1, y = 0 — exactly two points, even though those two directrices are parallel. That single example shows why the split has to be by opening direction, not by parallel directrices. The distractors sit exactly on the plausible slips: (A) 720 = 2(435-75) discards all 5C(6, 2) = 75 parallel-directrix pairs, forgetting the opposite-side ones do meet; (D) 840 = 2(435-15) keeps only the b > 0 half of the nested pairs; (E) 870 forgets the nested pairs entirely. One honest caveat: the 'no three concurrent' clause is load-bearing and is handed to you rather than proved. A direct check shows it is not literally true of this configuration — for instance (1/2,1/2) is at distance 1/√(2) from the focus and from each of the three directrices y = x+1, y = x-1, y = -x+2, so three of the parabolas pass through it. Counting the way the problem instructs, one fresh point per good pair, gives 810.
💡Key takeaway

Two parabolas with the same focus both measure distance to that same point, so subtracting their equations kills the square root and leaves a straight line — the pair meets in exactly two points unless the two curves open the very same way, and only 30 of the 435 pairs do.

  • Remove the absolute value
  • A parabola is two numbers
  • Subtract; the root cancels
  • Same direction means no meeting
  • Different directions: aim the line
  • One quadratic, discriminant p₁p₂
  • Both roots are real points
  • Count the pairs that fail
  • Multiply and finish