AMC 10 · 2014 · #14

Grade 9 algebranumber-theory
sequences-arithmeticsequences-geometricquadratic-equationspolynomial-factoring convert-to-algebracaseworkextreme-principle ↑ Prerequisites: sequences-arithmeticsequences-geometric
📏 Medium solution 💡 3 insights
Problem
The same three integers step evenly in one order and multiply evenly in another. Find the smallest possible largest one.

Pick an answer.

(A)
-2
(B)
1
(C)
2
(D)
4
(E)
6
How to solve
Strategy Convert to Algebra

Both words in the problem are definitions in disguise, so Tool #13 (Convert to Algebra) turns "arithmetic" into 2b=a+c and "geometric" into c²=ab. Two equations in three letters leave one degree of freedom, so Tool #4 (Introduce a Variable) keeps b as the single free parameter and expresses a and c through it. Tool #3 (Eliminate Possibilities) throws away the branch of the factored equation that collides with a < b < c. Tool #15 (Organize Information in More Ways) rewrites the whole triple in one parameter, which is what makes the inequality a < b < c collapse to a single condition. Only then does Tool #14 (Extreme Principle) pick the minimum, and the minimum has to be exhibited, not just bounded.

1STEP 1

Turn both words into equations

Both words become plain equations.

2b=a+c and c²=ab
2STEP 2

Use one equation to delete a

One equation deletes a variable.

a=2b-c → c²=(2b-c)b → c²+bc-2b²=0
3STEP 3

Factor and drop one branch

Factoring leaves two branches.

(c-b)(c+2b)=0 → c=b (rejected, since b < c) or c=-2b
4STEP 4

Rewrite the triple in one letter

The whole triple rides on one letter.

(a,b,c)=(4b, b, -2b), ratio=-1/2
5STEP 5

Let the ordering pin down b

The ordering makes that letter negative.

4b < b⇔ b < 0, b < -2b⇔ b < 0
6STEP 6

Minimize c over the family

The smallest largest value is 2, choice (C).

b ≤ -1 → c=-2b ≥ 2, (a,b,c)=(-4,-1,2) → (C)
Answer
2
The word "smallest" invites a negative answer, so the family is worth testing against every choice. Since c=-2b with b ≤ -1, the achievable values of c are precisely 2,4,6,8,…. Choice (A) -2 would force b=1, which is positive and breaks a < b < c (the triple would be 4,1,-2, in the wrong order). Choice (B) 1 is odd, and -2b is always even, so no integer b produces it. Choices (D) 4 and (E) 6 do occur, at b=-2 giving (-8,-2,4) and b=-3 giving (-12,-3,6), but both are larger than 2. The winner (-4,-1,2) checks out on both readings: -4,-1,2 has common difference 3, and -4,2,-1 has common ratio -1/2. So 2 is both attainable and minimal, confirming (C).
💡Key takeaway

Write each progression word as an equation, squeeze the three numbers down to one letter, and then the ordering tells you exactly which values that letter may take.

  • Turn both words into equations
  • Use one equation to delete a
  • Factor and drop one branch
  • Rewrite the triple in one letter
  • Let the ordering pin down b
  • Minimize c over the family