AMC 10 · 2021 · #17

Grade 9 geometry-2d
area-trianglesarea-trapezoidquadratic-equationsratio-proportion convert-to-algebraidentify-subproblemsbound-inequality-then-enumerate ↑ Prerequisites: area-trianglesarea-trapezoid
📏 Long solution 💡 4 insights 📊 Diagram
Problem
An isosceles trapezoid has parallel bases with the top shorter. A point inside is joined to all four vertices, cutting it into four triangles. Going clockwise from the triangle on the short base, their areas are 2, 3, 4, and 5. Find the ratio of the long base to the short base.

Pick an answer.

(A)
3
(B)
$2+\sqrt{2}$
(C)
$1+\sqrt{6}$
(D)
$2\sqrt{3}$
(E)
$3\sqrt{2}$
How to solve
Strategy Introduce a Variable

Tool #4 (Introduce a Variable) — nothing in the picture has a number attached except the four areas, so name what matters: let a = AB, b = CD, and let h₁, h₂ be the distances from P up to CD and down to AB. Tool #16 (Change Focus) — the two triangles that sit on the parallel bases are the useful ones, because each has a base that is one of the two unknowns and a height that is one of h₁, h₂. The two slanted triangles have no clean base or height, so do not chase them individually; use them only through the total area 14. Tool #7 (Identify Subproblems) supplies the link that closes the system: h₁ + h₂ is exactly the trapezoid's height. Tool #13 (Convert to Algebra) turns the three area facts into one equation in a and b. Tool #15 (Organize Information in More Ways) then rewrites that equation in the single quantity actually asked for, r = a/b, and Tool #3 (Eliminate Possibilities) throws out the root that violates AB > CD.

1STEP 1

Label the four areas

Label the four areas on the picture.

[PCD] = 2, [PBC] = 3, [PAB] = 4, [PDA] = 5, so [ABCD] = 2+3+4+5 = 14
2STEP 2

Name the bases and heights

Name the bases and the two heights.

a = AB, b = CD, r = a/b; h₁ = dist(P, CD), h₂ = dist(P, AB)
3STEP 3

Turn base triangles into heights

The two triangles give the heights.

1/2 b h₁ = 2 → h₁ = 4/b, and 1/2 a h₂ = 4 → h₂ = 8/a
4STEP 4

The heights fill the trapezoid

Together they make the full height.

h₁ + h₂ = h, that is, 4/b + 8/a = h
5STEP 5

Get the height from the total area

The total area gives the height again.

1/2(a+b)h = 14 → h = 28/(a+b)
6STEP 6

Set the two equal

Setting them equal makes an equation.

4/b + 8/a = 28/(a+b) → 4a(a+b) + 8b(a+b) = 28ab → 4a² + 12ab + 8b² = 28ab → a² - 4ab + 2b² = 0
7STEP 7

Rewrite in the ratio

Reduce it to the ratio alone.

a²/b² - 4 a/b + 2 = 0, and with r = a/b: r² - 4r + 2 = 0
8STEP 8

Solve the quadratic

Solve the quadratic.

r = (4 ± √(16 - 8))/2 = (4 ± 2√(2))/2 = 2 ± √(2)
9STEP 9

Reject the impossible root

What remains is two plus root two.

2 - √(2) ≈ 0.586 < 1 (rejected); r = AB/CD = 2 + √(2) ≈ 3.414 → (B)
Answer
2+√(2)
Build the trapezoid and check all four areas. Take b = CD = 1 and a = AB = 2 + √(2). Then h₁ = 4/b = 4 and h₂ = 8/a = 8/(2+√(2)) = (8(2-√(2)))/2 = 8 - 4√(2), so h = h₁ + h₂ = 12 - 4√(2) ≈ 6.343. The trapezoid's area is then 1/2(a+b)h = 1/2(3+√(2))(12-4√(2)) = 1/2(36 - 8) = 14, matching 2+3+4+5. Place A = (-a/2, 0), B = (a/2, 0), D = (-b/2, h), C = (b/2, h) — an honest isosceles trapezoid — and put P at height h₂ ≈ 2.343. Sliding P sideways keeps [PCD] = 2 and [PAB] = 4 fixed (their heights do not change) while trading area between the two leg triangles, whose total is locked at 14 - 6 = 8; at x ≈ 0.315 the split is exactly 3 and 5, and that P is inside the trapezoid. So a genuine configuration exists. One more sanity note: 2 + √(2) ≈ 3.414 sits between the long base being 3 and 4 times the short one, which matches a picture where the bottom triangle has twice the area of the top one but a much smaller height.
💡Key takeaway

The two triangles sitting on the parallel bases are the only ones worth measuring: each one's area tells you how far the point is from that base, and those two distances add up to the trapezoid's height. Set that against the trapezoid's own area formula and you get a² - 4ab + 2b² = 0; divide by b² and the answer is the root of r² - 4r + 2 = 0 bigger than 1, namely 2+√(2).

  • Label the four areas on the picture
  • Name the bases and the two heights
  • Turn the base triangles into height formulas
  • The two heights fill the trapezoid
  • Use the total area to get h again
  • Set the two expressions for h equal
  • Rewrite in the ratio r = a/b
  • Solve the quadratic
  • Reject the impossible root