AMC 10 · 2021 · #19

Grade 8 probability
probability-basicfundamental-counting-principlesystematic-enumerationcasework convert-to-algebrasystematic-enumerationbound-inequality-then-enumerate ↑ Prerequisites: probability-basicfundamental-counting-principle
📏 Long solution 💡 3 insights
Problem
Two fair dice are rolled. Each has some number of faces, at least six, numbered from one upward. Two facts pin the dice down: rolling a sum of seven is exactly three quarters as likely as rolling a sum of ten, and rolling a sum of twelve has probability one twelfth. Find the smallest possible total number of faces.

Pick an answer.

(A)
16
(B)
17
(C)
18
(D)
19
(E)
20
How to solve
Strategy Introduce a Variable

The dice are unknown, so name their face counts a and b and turn every sentence of the problem into a statement about counts of ordered pairs. Because all ab outcomes are equally likely, each probability is (number of pairs with that sum) divided by ab, and the shared denominator makes the first condition a pure counting statement. The key structural fact is that the count for a given sum is capped: only finitely many ordered pairs add to 7, 10, or 12, and the dice being at least 6-sided already guarantees most of them exist. Pushing on those caps squeezes a to a single value, after which the sum-12 condition becomes one linear equation in b. Since we want the least total, we take the smallest surviving pair.

1STEP 1

Name the sample space

Every probability shares one denominator.

P(sum = s) = n_s/ab, a ≥ 6, b ≥ 6, a ≤ b
2STEP 2

Count the ways to roll seven

There are only six ways.

n₇ = |{(1,6),(2,5),(3,4),(4,3),(5,2),(6,1)}| = 6
3STEP 3

Convert the ratio into a count

The ratio gives the sum-ten count.

n₇/ab = 3/4·n₁₀/ab ⟹ 6 = 3/4n₁₀ ⟹ n₁₀ = 8
4STEP 4

Squeeze the face counts

That count fixes one die's faces.

n₁₀ = (min(a,9)) - (max(1,10-b)) + 1 = 8 ⟹ a = 8, b ≥ 9
5STEP 5

Count the ways to roll twelve

The count splits by the other die's size.

n₁₂ = b - 3, & 9 ≤ b ≤ 11, ; 8, & b ≥ 11.
6STEP 6

Solve the equation

Two candidates come out.

n₁₂ = ab/12 = 2b/3; b-3 = 2b/3 → b = 9, 8 = 2b/3 → b = 12
7STEP 7

Take the smaller and check

The smaller total is 17.

(a,b) = (8,9): P(7) = 6/72 = 1/12 = 3/4·8/72, P(12) = 6/72 = 1/12, a+b = 17
Answer
17
Choice (A) 16 would need a + b = 16 with a < = b and a = 8, so both dice would have 8 faces; but then the pairs (1,9) and (9,1) are both missing and only 7 ordered pairs sum to 10, breaking the 3/4 ratio. Every other choice is either impossible for the same reason or larger than 17, and 17 itself was verified outcome by outcome on the 8-by-9 pair. The numbers also feel right: P(7) = P(12) = 1/12 on the 8-by-9 dice, and 12 divides 72, which is exactly what the clean probability 1/12 was hinting at.
💡Key takeaway

When dice are fair, probability questions are really counting questions: write every clue as a count of ordered pairs over the same total, and the unknown dice sizes get squeezed out one at a time.

  • Name the dice and the sample space
  • Count the ways to roll 7
  • Convert the ratio into a count
  • Squeeze a from the sum-10 cap
  • Count the ways to roll 12
  • Solve the sum-12 equation
  • Take the smaller total and check it