AMC 10 · 2010 · #17
Grade 7 geometry-3dPick an answer.
AMC 10 2010 problem © Mathematical Association of America (MAA AMC). Reproduced for educational use.
The leftover solid is an awkward frame shape, but the material that was removed is made of simple boxes. So instead of measuring what stays, measure what is taken away and subtract it from the full cube. The catch is that the three tunnels overlap, so counting the removed boxes is its own subproblem that needs care about the shared center.
Volume of the full cube
Before any drilling, the whole cube of side 3 has volume 27.
Everything left over must come out of these 27 cubic inches, so it is the number to subtract from.
5.MD.C.5Change Focus Count The ComplementVolume of one straight tunnel
One hole is a 2-by-2 square running through the full depth 3, a box of volume 12.
A hole punched straight through is just a long box, and a box's volume is length times width times height.
5.MD.C.5Visualize Spatial RelationshipsThree tunnels share one center
One tunnel per pair of opposite faces gives 3 tunnels, and all three share the central 2-by-2-by-2 cube of volume 8.
Where two tunnels cross they carve out the same central block, so that block cannot be counted more than once.
7.G.B.6Identify SubproblemsAdd up the removed material correctly
Inclusion-exclusion: three tunnels of 12, minus the three overlaps of 8, plus the center 8 back, removes 20 in all.
Adding the tunnels overcounts the shared center, so you take the overlaps out and put the once-removed center back exactly once.
Adding the tunnels overcounts the shared centre, so the overlaps must be taken back out.
▸ Why?
When groups overlap, adding them double-counts the shared part, which has to be subtracted off.
▸ Why?
The cube is exactly what stays plus what is removed, so the removed amount must be counted once.
Subtract to get what remains
What is left is the cube minus everything drilled away: 27 minus 20 is 7 cubic inches, choice (A).
What is left is simply the starting cube with the removed volume taken out.
5.MD.C.5Change Focus Count The ComplementWhen holes overlap, don't just add up what you drill out; count the shared part once so you don't erase too much.
- Volume of the full cube
- Volume of one straight tunnel
- Three tunnels share one center
- Add up the removed material correctly
- Subtract to get what remains