AMC 10 · 2013 · #17
Grade 6 logicnumber-theoryPick an answer.
AMC 10 2013 problem © Mathematical Association of America (MAA AMC). Reproduced for educational use.
Following every trade one by one would take dozens of steps. Instead, re-describe the tokens by giving each color a point value chosen so that every trade keeps the total number of points the same. Then the total is fixed from start to finish, and the only thing left to pin down is how the leftover points split among the few tokens that remain at the end.
Find each trade's net effect
Red booth: lose 2 red, gain 1 blue and 1 silver. Blue booth: lose 3 blue, gain 1 red and 1 silver. Each trade adds 1 silver.
Boiling each booth down to a plus-and-minus list makes the two trades easy to compare.
4.OA.A.3Organize Information In More WaysGive each token a point value
Set red 4, blue 3, silver 5. Then 2 red = 8 = 1 silver + 1 blue, and 3 blue = 9 = 1 silver + 1 red: every trade is an even swap.
If both booths trade equal points for equal points, the total point value can never change.
If both booths trade equal value for equal value, the total value can never change.
▸ Why?
What is handed in is matched by what is handed back, so the two changes cancel exactly.
▸ Why?
The total is exactly the value of every token added, so it ties the start to the finish.
Compute the fixed total
No trade changes the total, so the ending total equals the start: 75 red and 75 blue are worth 525 points.
One fixed number, 525 points, ties the messy start to the messy end.
4.NBT.B.5Organize Information In More WaysDescribe the end state
Trading stops with fewer than 2 red and fewer than 3 blue, so red is 0 or 1 and blue is 0, 1, or 2. Silver is never spent.
Only a tiny handful of red and blue tokens can survive to the end.
6.NS.C.7Work BackwardsSplit the 525 points at the end
Silver is 5 points each, so the leftover 4·red + 3·blue must be a multiple of 5. Of the allowed leftovers only 0 and 10 qualify.
The silver count must be whole, so only leftovers that are multiples of 5 can actually happen.
4.OA.B.4Extreme PrincipleRule out zero-zero and finish
The last trade always hands a token back, so 0 red and 0 blue is impossible. Leftover 1 red and 2 blue give 515 / 5 = 103 silvers.
The last trade always returns a coin, so you can never empty both colors at once.
4.OA.A.3Extreme PrincipleGive each token a point value so every trade is an even swap, then the unchanging total tells you the answer no matter how the trades happen.
- Find each trade's net effect
- Give each token a point value
- Compute the fixed total
- Describe the end state
- Split the 525 points at the end
- Rule out zero-zero and finish