Competition · AMC preparation · step 4 of 4
AMC 8 · 2009 · #11
Grade 6 number-theoryPick an answer.
AMC 8 2009 problem © Mathematical Association of America (MAA AMC). Reproduced for educational use.
The question asks for a difference in head counts, but we cannot count heads until we know the pencil price. Tool #7 (Identify Subproblems) splits the work cleanly: (1) pin down the pencil cost c, then (2) compute (195 - 143) / c for the difference. Subproblem (1) is a number-theory hunt: c must divide both 143 and 195, so we list the factors of each (Tool #2) and keep only the common ones. Tool #3 (Eliminate Possibilities) then rules out the bad common factors — c = 1 would force 195 sixth-grade buyers in a class of only 30 — leaving a unique price.
Switch to cents
In cents the totals are $1.43 = 143 and $1.95 = 195, so the price c must divide both 143 and 195.
Naming the two subproblems — "which c is allowed" and "how many buyers" — is the Tool #7 move that turns a vague word problem into a two-step calculation.
The pencil's whole-cent price must divide both 143 and 195 exactly, so it is a factor the two totals share.
▸ Why?
Inside each grade every buyer paid the same whole-cent price for exactly one pencil, so that grade's total is the price counted once for each buyer — the number of buyers times the price.
▸ Why?
Adding the same price once per buyer is repeated addition of equal amounts, which is exactly the count that multiplication gives.
▸ Why?
Since 143 and 195 are each the price times a whole number of buyers, splitting either total back into price-sized shares returns that whole buyer count with nothing left over, so the price goes into each total evenly.
▸ Why?
Division is the reverse of multiplication, so a total built as the price times a whole number comes apart into price-sized groups with no remainder.
Factor both totals
Factor each total to list its divisors: 143 = 11 × 13 and 195 = 3 × 5 × 13.
Writing out the prime factorization is the Tool #2 systematic list of factors, and recognizing 11 and 13 as primes is the Grade 4 factor/multiple skill.
4.OA.B.4Make A Systematic ListTake the greatest common factor
The only prime shared by the two factorizations is 13, so the common factors of 143 and 195 are just 1 and 13.
The GCF reading off prime factorizations is the Grade 6 number-theory move that turns the systematic list into a short candidate set.
6.NS.B.4Make A Systematic ListRule out 1 cent
A 1-cent pencil needs = 195 buyers, but there are only 30 sixth graders, so c = 1 is out and c = 13.
Crossing off the candidate that breaks the " ≤ 30 sixth graders" constraint is the Tool #3 elimination step.
4.OA.A.3Eliminate PossibilitiesDivide the difference by 13
Sixth graders paid 195 - 143 = 52 more cents, and each extra pencil is 13 cents, so the head-count gap is .
Subtracting the totals first (instead of counting each group separately) is the cleanest Tool #7 path; the final 52 ÷ 13 = 4 is a Grade 4 whole-number division.
4.NBT.B.6Identify SubproblemsOnce you spot that the pencil price is the greatest common factor of 143 and 195, this AMC 8 problem reduces to a Grade 6 GCF on top of plain Grade 4 division.
- Switch to cents
- Factor both totals
- Take the greatest common factor
- Rule out 1 cent
- Divide the difference by 13
A parent dashboard for the family lives at sensimlab.com.