Competition · AMC preparation · step 4 of 4
AMC 8 · 2012 · #22
Grade 6 arithmeticPick an answer.
AMC 8 2012 problem © Mathematical Association of America (MAA AMC). Reproduced for educational use.
Instead of analyzing all ways to pick the three unknown integers, solve the easier extreme cases first (Tool #9): What is the smallest median we can force? What is the largest? Once we have the range, use Tool #2 to systematically check each integer in that range and confirm it is reachable. The median of 9 numbers is always the 5th element after sorting, so the question reduces to: which positions in the sorted known list can become the 5th slot when we slide three free integers into the line?
Pin down which value is the median
With 9 distinct integers in ascending order the median is the 5th number, so we hunt for every integer that can occupy that slot.
Reducing "median of a 9-element set" to "the 5th smallest" is the Grade 6 definition of median for an odd-sized data set.
6.SP.B.5Solve An Easier Related ProblemFind the smallest possible median
Slide all three unknowns below 2 so the known six shift up; the 5th slot then lands on 3 — the smallest possible median.
Solving the extreme "how small can it be?" first is the Tool #9 move — replace the general question with an easier boundary version.
6.SP.B.5Solve An Easier Related ProblemFind the largest possible median
Slide all three unknowns above 14 so the known six drop down; the 5th slot then lands on 9 — the largest possible median.
The companion extreme — "how large can it be?" — caps the range. Together the two extremes bound every possible median between 3 and 9.
Placing all three unknown integers above 14 makes the middle value of the nine sorted numbers equal 9 — the largest median the set can reach.
▸ Why?
The middle value of nine numbers in order is always the 5th one, because it has four numbers below it and four numbers above it.
▸ Why?
Pairing each of the four numbers below with one of the four numbers above matches the two sides one for one, so the sides are the same size and exactly one number is left alone in the center as the middle.
▸ Why?
Since all three unknowns are larger than every known number, the six known numbers keep the six lowest slots, so the 5th slot holds the fifth-smallest known number, which is 9.
▸ Why?
The nine ordered slots split with no gaps and no overlaps into the six lowest, filled by the knowns, and the three highest, filled by the unknowns, so counting up through the knowns 2, 3, 4, 6, 9 reaches the 5th slot exactly at 9.
Check every value in between
Between the extremes every integer works: give each value in 3 to 9 a witness arrangement by dropping the unknowns into the right gaps.
A systematic list of one witness per value (Tool #2) shows nothing in {3, …, 9} gets skipped.
6.SP.B.5Make A Systematic ListCount from 3 to 9
Count the integers from 3 to 9 inclusive: 9 - 3 + 1 = 7 possible medians.
Counting consecutive integers from a to b as b - a + 1 is a standard Grade 4 word-problem move.
4.OA.A.3Make A Systematic ListThis AMC 8 problem only needs the Grade 6 definition of median — the middle number of a sorted list — that you already know!
- Pin down which value is the median
- Find the smallest possible median
- Find the largest possible median
- Check every value in between
- Count from 3 to 9
A parent dashboard for the family lives at sensimlab.com.